Why Justin Trudeau Would Bring Back Gerald Butts Amidst SNC-Lavalin Controversy

Recent discussions around bringing back Gerald Butts for the Liberal Party of Canada have sparked considerable debate, particularly in light of the SNC-Lavalin scandal. Many argue that bringing Butts back is an unnecessary move, given the fallout from this scandal. However, a closer look at the issues reveals that the concerns are largely misplaced.

The SNC-Lavalin Controversy: A Matter of Procedure, Not Irregularity

First, it is important to dispel the notion that the SNC-Lavalin scandal was a significant issue. It was not a scandal in any meaningful sense. During her testimony, former Justice Minister Jody Wilson-Raybould did not present the matter as a criminal act per se. Rather, she expressed concerns about the improper pressure she felt, showing a lack of understanding about how government functions. Procedures were not followed properly, and that's an issue, but it doesn't constitute a criminal offense.

Resolution of Previous Testimonies and Clarifications

It's crucial to consider the testimonies and statements made. John Wu, who testified before the Independent Parliamentary Counsel, clearly stated that Gerald Butts was not the problem. He pointed out that the issue lay with other staff members who were applying pressure, suggesting that the problems were not with Butts himself. This refutes the notion that Butts was fundamentally at fault.

Role of Gerald Butts in the Liberal Campaign

Another key point is that Gerald Butts is being hired as a campaign worker, not a public servant. His role is to assist in the election campaign, which he has done successfully for other political parties at various levels of government. It would be hypocritical to question his involvement purely because he is returning to a position he holds well and has proven himself in.

Additionally, the hypocrisy of opposition parties in questioning Butts’ involvement underscores their own ethical bankruptcy. It is disingenuous for them to raise such issues when they have their own corrupt candidates running for re-election. For instance, Warren Kinsella, a former columnist for National Post, is now helping Elizabeth May, a Green Party candidate. Similarly, Hamish Marshall, who was once the Director of Rebel Media, is now Scheer’s campaign director for the Conservative Party. The Republicans, who have a history of corruption, have their own incumbents running for re-election. Thus, it is more concerning to question the Liberals when there are obvious examples of similar behavior elsewhere.

Friendship and Trust Between Trudeau and Butts

It should also be noted that Gerald Butts and Justin Trudeau have known each other for a long time. Jody Wilson-Raybould, the former Justice Minister, has now distanced herself from the Liberal party and is likely disinterested in further involvement. In the meantime, Gerald Butts, a trusted and well-regarded figure in Liberal circles, is returning for the campaign. His role is strategic given his longstanding relationship with Trudeau and his proven track record in political campaigns.

Conclusion: The Future of Gerald Butts in Politics

The overarching argument, it seems, is that Gerald Butts' return for the campaign reflects a natural and expected continuation of his engagement with the Liberal Party. Assuming a Liberal victory, it is quite possible that Butts will return to his previous position in the Prime Minister's Office. His involvement in the campaign could be seen as a natural extension of his political career.

Ultimately, the hiring of Gerald Butts for the Liberal campaign is best seen as a strategic decision rather than an ethical concern. It is part of the natural political landscape and does not deserve the scrutiny it is receiving from the opposition.