Why Hema Malini, a Senior BJP MP, Is Not Made Minister While Smriti Irani Is

Introduction

Hema Malini and Smriti Irani are significant figures within the Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP). Despite their notable roles and seniority within the party, the decision-making processes often favor younger, more visually appealing candidates for ministerial positions. This article will explore the reasons behind these choices and the implications for Indian politics.

The Circumstances of Hema Malini and Smriti Irani

Both Hema Malini and Smriti Irani hold their respective positions as Members of Parliament (MPs) and have played important roles within the BJP. However, there is a stark difference in their approaches and the way their credentials are perceived.

Hema Malini has a distinguished background as an actress and maintains a highly respected professional image. Her journey from Bollywood to politics has been marked by a conscious decision to preserve her reputation and dignity, a commitment that has been evident throughout her career. She joined politics primarily for the sake of power and respect, not for monetary gain. Her choices have often been influenced by the need to protect her image, a lesson many contemporary film industry personalities can learn from.

Conversely, Smriti Irani's ascent to ministerial positions is often seen as a direct result of her close association with Narendra Modi. Irani's tenure as Minister of Textiles was marked by controversy, leading to her eventual removal from the portfolio. This decision was influenced by internal party dynamics rather than her performance in the ministry.

Reasons for the Different Treatment

The BJP, like many political parties, has its own set of criteria for ministerial appointments. These can be based on party loyalty, promoter connections, and even personal appearances. The notion that "Old Goats prefer Green Grass" encapsulates the idea that seasoned politicians may not fit the desired image that the BJP is pushing today.

Hema Malini's age and dignified presence make her a symbol of a bygone era, which may not align well with the modern, youthful image that the BJP aims to project. Furthermore, given her already established respect and image, additional ministerial roles may not provide the needed visibility or value to the party.

Smriti Irani's rapid rise to prominence, despite her initial performance issues, can be attributed to her close association with Narendra Modi and the strategic moves within the party to balance different factions. Her younger age and more approachable personality make her a preferred candidate for ministerial positions.

Implications for BJP and Indian Politics

The success of such strategies lies in the party's ability to maintain an image that is appealing and relevant to the modern voter. However, it also raises questions about merit and the value of experience in politics. The decision to appoint young faces over experienced ones can impact the stability and effectiveness of ministerial positions.

The broader political landscape in India is moving towards a more visual and accessible form of leadership. While this may attract a younger audience, it also risks marginalizing experienced and respected leaders like Hema Malini. The implications of these choices on the overall governance and policy effectiveness must be carefully considered.

Conclusion

While Hema Malini and Smriti Irani hold significant roles within the BJP, the reasons for their different treatments as ministerial candidates are complex and multifaceted. The decision to prioritize younger, more visually appealing faces over experienced leaders like Hema Malini reflects a broader trend in Indian politics. However, it is essential to recognize the valuable contributions of seasoned politicians who have maintained their integrity and respect in the face of changing political dynamics.

To the aspiring politicians of today, especially those transitioning from the realm of entertainment to politics, Hema Malini's example emphasizes the importance of maintaining a clean image and personal respect even in the most challenging circumstances.