Why Ben Shapiro Faces Criticism from the Alt-Right: A Socratic Examination

Many have noted Ben Shapiro's reputation as a prominent political commentator. While he is certainly not the favorite of all, it's worth exploring the question of why the Alt-Right would criticize him. Is there a valid argument to be found, or is the criticism perhaps more nuanced than it appears?

The Question and Its Underlying Assumptions

When we ask why the Alt-Right might 'hate' Ben Shapiro, we must first consider the underlying assumptions that this question presupposes. The term 'Alt-Right' is often used as a catch-all to describe a loose collection of individuals and groups. However, the term is not well-defined, and there are no clearly established foundational facts to support the idea that the Alt-Right has a unified stance.

The Illusory Definition of 'Alt-Right'

According to one online source, the Alt-Right is described as 'an ideological grouping associated with extreme conservative or reactionary viewpoints, characterized by a rejection of mainstream politics and by the use of online media to disseminate deliberately controversial content.' However, this definition is riddled with subjectivity. Who can objectively define what constitutes 'extreme conservative or reactionary viewpoints'? Who can objectively determine whether someone rejects 'mainstream politics'? And who can objectively decide what constitutes 'deliberately controversial content'?

Interrogating the Question

According to the Socratic method, the question of 'Why the Alt-Right hates Ben Shapiro' is inherently unanswerable because the terms lack clear and objective definitions. The question prompts us to ask: What do you mean by 'against' and by 'Alt-Right'? These are critical inquiries that challenge the very premise of the question.

Shapiro's Repeated Agreement with Alt-Right Views

Even though Ben Shapiro often repeats the points made by the Alt-Right, it doesn't necessarily mean that he is consistently aligned with their views. To his critics, Shapiro's stance on specific issues can appear contradictory. For instance, while the Alt-Right is frequently associated with anti-establishment politics and conservative viewpoints, Shapiro is not always seen as the epitome of these beliefs. This discrepancy can lead to tension and criticism.

Shapiro and Family Losses in School Mass Shootings

A significant point of contention is Shapiro's involvement in discussions about families who have lost children in mass school killings. His public remarks and stances on these issues have sometimes been seen as insensitive or too confrontational by some members of the Alt-Right. Critics argue that his approach might be deemed too harsh, especially given the emotional impact on the families involved.

Shapiro's Critics' Perspective

To some, the fact that Shapiro isn't 'fascist enough' is a criticism. While he is certainly involved in controversial discussions, his critics argue that he might be too aggressively confrontational. This attitude is seen as a form of fascism in their view. However, defining Shapiro's views as fascist is a subjective claim and does not necessarily reflect a universally accepted position.

Reevaluating the Label 'Alt-Right'

It's worth reconsidering the use of the term 'Alt-Right' and whether it helps or hinders our understanding of the complex political landscape. Terms like 'Neo-Nazi' might be more precise and accurate, especially when discussing entities with a history of collaboration with Nazi forces. For example, the KAPOs during the Second World War were SS officers who were placed in concentration camps to enforce discipline and order, often at the expense of their fellow prisoners.

The Kapo System in Nazi-Occupied Europe

The KAPOs were recruited from the Jewish population and were forced to act as enforcers for the SS. They wore distinctive clothing, including the Judenstern (a star of David) and Lagerpolizist (camp police) armbands. The system was designed to create a sense of collaboration and to foster a sense of implicit loyalty to the oppressors. This system was particularly visible in camps such as Salaspils in Latvia, where KAPOs were used to uphold the regime.

Conclusion

The question of why the Alt-Right 'hates' Ben Shapiro is a complex one that requires careful examination of the terms and definitions involved. While Shapiro's critics may see him as too aggressive or not 'fascist enough,' these views are subjective and may not reflect the views of the broader political landscape. Ultimately, understanding the motivations of the Alt-Right and other political movements requires a nuanced perspective that goes beyond simplistic labels and definitions.