The Myth of Scottish Jobs Dependent on Trident

This article explores the myth surrounding the dependency of Scottish jobs on the Trident nuclear programme. By analyzing historical data and recent studies, it aims to provide a comprehensive understanding of the economic and social impact of this issue.

Eleven Jobs, Not Thousands

A few years ago, a detailed report was published that addressed the question of how many Scottish jobs are dependent on the Trident nuclear programme. The answer was quite surprising: just 114. This stark contrast between the official figures and the claims made by politicians highlights the need for a more transparent and accurate analysis of the program's economic impact.

The History of Polaris and Beyond

From the days of Polaris onwards, the Rosyth and the Solway Firth areas have faced significant challenges. These areas were already in a state of run-down, and unemployment rates were among the highest in Scotland. However, the claims made by Labour MSPs, such as Jackie Baillie, have often been exaggerated. Numbers ranging up to 19,000 were cited, but a closer examination of the data reveals that most of these figures are misleading.

False Claims and Local Employment

According to the data, about 18,500 people were counted in the initial figures, but these numbers largely represent employees who commute to and from the area on a weekly basis. The actual number of people employed locally due to the Trident programme is significantly lower. Official figures indicate that at most, just over 500 people are directly employed in this area. This includes both Rosyth and the Solway Firth.

The Reality of the Trident Workforce

It is estimated that there are about 300 people working on the Trident programme in the area. However, the local community often complains that very little of the spending from these workers flows into the local economy. While the programme undoubtedly provides some jobs, the economic benefits are far from the extravagant claims made by some politicians. The local area continues to struggle with high unemployment and run-down infrastructure.

The Occasional Sarcasm

The article concludes with a note of local sarcasm: 'If weaseling politicians were to move to the Thames, it would not affect a damn thing. And just one request: take your shite out of Rosyth and the Solway Firth as well!' This humorous remark underscores the lasting negative impact of the programme on the area's image and community welfare.

Conclusion

While the Trident nuclear programme may provide some jobs, the claims of its significant economic impact on the Scottish economy are exaggerated. The true number of local jobs is much lower than the figures often cited. The area continues to face challenges, and the economic benefits from the programme should be critically examined and properly communicated.