Why Does Hamas Refrain from Returning Hostages and Ceasing the War?

In recent discussions and media coverage, Hamas officials have made it clear that they do not consider themselves a governing or managing entity for Gazans. Instead, they assert that charitable organizations and the United Nations (UN) should be responsible for these functions. This assertion raises several concerning questions and points to the core of the conflict.

Hamas's Role and Approach to Governance

Hamas, by its own description, does not see itself as a governing or managing entity for the people of Gaza. They have stated that the responsibility lies with the United Nations, specifically the UN Relief and Works Agency (UNRWA) and other charitable organizations. This perspective suggests that Hamas sees its role more in terms of a liberation movement rather than a governing body. However, as the de facto rulers of Gaza, they have significant control over the lives of Gazans. This control is evident in their use of aid and resources, which has raised significant concerns.

Primary Goals and Hatred towards Israel

Hamas emphasizes its sole goal to be the elimination of Israel and Jews. This objective is one of the key reasons why any ceasefire or return of hostages is highly unlikely. In a statement made by Hamas, they have been clear that their primary focus is not on the welfare of Gazans but on achieving their ultimate political and military objectives. This unflinching hatred and determination to achieve their goals implies a disregard for the lives of Palestinians and other civilians caught in the crossfire.

Allocation of Aid and Resources

According to the reports and statements from Hamas, a significant portion of the aid and resources provided to Gaza is not allocated for the welfare and development of the people. Instead, these funds are used for a variety of military and infrastructure projects, such as tunnels, weapons, and arsenals. Additionally, a substantial amount is reportedly spent on the luxury living conditions of Hamas leaders and their families outside the Gaza strip. This misallocation of resources highlights the stark disconnection between their stated goals and the actual use of funds.

The Hypocrisy of Cease-Fire Proposals

The state of affairs in Gaza makes it clear that any suggestion of a cease-fire is highly misguided. For Hamas, a cease-fire is merely a strategic pause in their ongoing campaign to eliminate Israel. During such a ceasefire, they would continue to prepare and strengthen their capabilities, while any suggestions of returning hostages or prisoners would be seen as a weakness by their supporters and an unfair advantage by their enemies.

Questions of Responsibility and Historial Context

The conflict in Gaza is not limited to the present moment. It has deep historical roots, with the current Palestinian struggle against Israeli occupation spanning decades. Historical perspectives, including the Oslo Accords and subsequent events, have contributed to the current state of affairs. While the specific details of each hostage situation vary, the overarching issue is the ongoing cycle of violence and the reluctance of Hamas to make compromises that could lead to a meaningful resolution.

Conclusion: Is a Cease-Fire Feasible?

In conclusion, given the goals and actions of Hamas, a ceasefire or the return of hostages is not a viable solution. Any such proposals would likely be exploited by Hamas to further their political and military objectives. The de facto rulers of Gaza are not interested in a sustainable peace with Israel. Instead, they continue to focus on building their military capabilities and propaganda efforts, seeing any cessation of hostilities as a temporary setback rather than a step towards peace.

Keywords

Hamas Gaza Israel hostage cease-fire

References

1. Hamas says charities should run Gaza, says UN access brief to Brookings Institution

2. How Hamas Fueled the Middle East Conflict and Terrorist Activities - Crisis Group

3. Gaza Is Set to Receive $135M in Aid But Isolates Hamas - Jerusalem Post